New Agreement Sparks Debate Over Privacy and Tax Compliance

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has agreed to share certain taxpayer information about immigrants with U.S. law enforcement agencies involved in criminal investigations. This decision follows a newly signed agreement between the Treasury Department and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). The memorandum of understanding (MOU) sets out how this information will be disclosed when law enforcement makes a valid request. While officials say this is only for criminal matters, advocacy groups worry about the wider effects.

Key Points:

1. Data Sharing: IRS will share immigrant taxpayer data in criminal probes.
2. Criminal Focus: Officials state it’s strictly for criminal investigations.
3. Privacy Concerns: Advocacy groups worry about confidentiality.
4. ITIN Holders: Potential impact on undocumented immigrants paying taxes.

Why the IRS Will Share Tax Data

The agreement comes as the federal government continues to focus on enforcing immigration laws. Officials argue that the MOU follows existing laws and includes measures to protect taxpayer privacy. The Justice Department’s tax division explains that the agreement “permits the lawful exchange of information for taxpayers under criminal investigation or subject to criminal proceedings.”

The IRS has stressed that this is not a broad sharing of data for general immigration enforcement. Instead, it will focus on criminal cases, such as individuals who stay in the U.S. after being ordered to leave or those who illegally re-enter the country after being deported.

However, immigrant advocacy groups are concerned that this change could undo long-standing policies that protected the confidentiality of undocumented immigrants who pay taxes using Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers (ITINs).

What the Government Says:

1. Legal Compliance: Agreement follows existing laws.
2. Privacy Protection: Measures are in place to safeguard data.
3. Criminal Focus: Limited to criminal investigations.

Lawsuit Seeks to Block IRS Data Sharing

Several organizations that support immigrants and workers, including Centro de Trabajadores Unidos and Inclusive Action for the City, have filed a lawsuit to stop the IRS from sharing this taxpayer data. They argue that Section 6103 of the Internal Revenue Code prevents the disclosure of tax return information for civil immigration purposes.

The groups believe that the IRS’s new policy goes against previous interpretations of the law. In 2017, the IRS said it could not share taxpayer information with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) under Section 6103. Now, the lawsuit claims, the agency needs to provide a clear legal reason for changing its stance.

The plaintiffs are asking for a preliminary injunction to prevent any data transfers while the court case is ongoing. A previous request to temporarily block the data sharing was denied by U.S. District Judge Dabney Friedrich.

Legal Challenge:

1. Section 6103: Plaintiffs argue it prohibits disclosure for civil immigration.
2. Policy Change: Groups say IRS is changing its interpretation of the law.
3. Preliminary Injunction: Lawsuit seeks to temporarily block data sharing.

Concerns About Impact on Tax Compliance

Critics are worried that this agreement could discourage immigrants, especially those without legal status, from voluntarily complying with tax laws. The U.S. tax system relies heavily on people reporting their own income. Many undocumented immigrants use ITINs to pay income taxes, even though they are not legal residents.

The Tax Law Center at New York University suggests that this cooperation between the IRS and DHS could make immigrants less likely to file taxes. If people fear their information could be used against them in immigration enforcement, they might choose not to file at all. Experts warn this could lead to a significant loss of tax revenue for the federal government.

Advocates emphasize that simply being in the country without legal status is not a criminal offense. However, recent policy interpretations are blurring the lines between civil and criminal immigration enforcement, increasing fears that taxpayer data could be misused.

Potential Negative Effects:

1. Reduced Compliance: Immigrants may be less likely to file taxes.
2. Lost Revenue: Federal government could lose billions in tax dollars.
3. Fear of Misuse: Blurring of civil and criminal enforcement raises concerns.

DHS and Treasury Defend the Agreement

A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security defended the agreement, stating that sharing data is necessary for security reasons and law enforcement. The spokesperson emphasized that tax data could help identify individuals involved in criminal activity, prevent the fraudulent use of public benefits, and ensure public records are accurate.

The Treasury Department echoed this view, saying that the agreement “establishes a clear and secure process” and is based on long-standing legal authority.

Government Justification:

1. Security Concerns: Data sharing is needed for security.
2. Preventing Fraud: Helps stop misuse of public benefits.
3. Accurate Records: Aids in maintaining correct public information.
4. Legal Authority: Agreement is based on existing laws.

Ongoing Legal Battle

The legal challenge, Centro de Trabajadores Unidos v. Bessent, is currently being heard in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. The plaintiffs argue that DHS wants to use the data to locate undocumented workers, which is not allowed under Section 6103 without a court order.

Until a final decision is made, concerns remain about how the IRS will balance the need to keep taxpayer data confidential with the demands of law enforcement. Legal experts and tax professionals are closely watching this case to see how this precedent might affect how taxpayers behave and how immigration laws are enforced.

What’s Next:

1. Court Case: Centro de Trabajadores Unidos v. Bessent is ongoing.
2. Legal Precedent: Outcome could set a new standard for data sharing.
3. Monitoring the Impact: Experts watching for effects on taxpayers and enforcement.

As a professional – Revolutionize your tax workflow with our complete suite of tools: onboarding links, initial interviews, compliance planning, calendars, messaging, task management, and TaxMan for advanced tax research. Please sign up.  Our resource directory also offers valuable links to assist in managing various financial and legal aspects of a business or individual. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter: https://bit.ly/4ilgFtk 

You will get:

1. Tax News & Regulations Updates
2. New Court Cases Explained
3. Upcoming Podcast Alerts
4. IRS-ready Guides to Present or Share with Your Advisor