Freelancers Beware: Misclassifying Income Leads to IRS Penalties

A recent Tax Court decision involving a freelance movie critic serves as a stark reminder for freelancers and online sellers: accurate income classification is crucial. The court ruled against the taxpayer, who attempted to avoid self-employment tax by incorrectly reporting business income as “other income.”

The Case of Clark, TC Memo 2025-13: A Critical Lesson

The Tax Court’s ruling in Clark, TC Memo 2025-13 (2/5/25) highlights the importance of understanding and adhering to self-employment tax rules. The taxpayer’s attempt to circumvent these rules resulted in back taxes, penalties, and interest.

Understanding Self-Employment Tax

Self-employment tax is the equivalent of FICA taxes for employees, covering Social Security and Medicare.

1. Employee Contributions:
   1. 6.2% for Social Security (OASDI) on wages up to $176,100 in 2025.
   2. 1.45% for Medicare on all earnings.
2. Self-Employed Contributions:
   1. 12.4% for Social Security.
   2. 2.9% for Medicare.
   3. Half of the self-employment tax is deductible.
3. “Other Income” vs. Self-Employment Income:
   1. Most business income is subject to self-employment tax.
   2. Certain “other income” (e.g., fuel tax credits, interest) is exempt.

How the Movie Critic Misstepped

The taxpayer, a freelance movie critic and memorabilia seller, made a critical error in classifying his income.

Details of the Taxpayer’s Income

1. Freelance Writing: Earned $8,250 from movie reviews.
2. Online Memorabilia Sales: Generated nearly $42,000 via a third-party marketplace.
3. Incorrect Classification: Reported all $50,000 as “other income” instead of business income on Schedule C.
4. IRS Action: Initially issued a refund, then reversed its decision, assessed a deficiency, and imposed penalties.
5. Taxpayer’s Argument: Claimed the initial refund was a “concession” of his position.

Tax Court’s Firm Ruling

The Tax Court rejected the taxpayer’s argument, emphasizing that business income cannot be classified as “other income” to avoid self-employment tax.

Key Court Findings

1. Business Income Subject to Self-Employment Tax: The taxpayer’s income was clearly derived from business activities and therefore subject to self-employment tax.
2. Initial Refund Not an Acceptance: The IRS’s initial refund did not indicate acceptance of the taxpayer’s incorrect classification.
3. Third-Party Reporting: Reports from third-party marketplaces were based on actual income earned, even if the taxpayer classified it incorrectly.
4. Penalties and Interest: The taxpayer was liable for back taxes, interest, and an accuracy-related penalty.

Critical Takeaways for Freelancers and Online Sellers

This case provides valuable lessons for anyone operating as a freelancer or online seller.

Essential Tax Practices

1. Accurate Income Reporting: Report all business income on Schedule C.
2. Online Sales Subject to Tax: Income from online sales is generally subject to self-employment tax.
3. Refunds Do Not Equal Approval: IRS refunds do not guarantee the accuracy of your tax return.
4. Review Tax Returns: Always review your tax return for accuracy, even if prepared by a professional.
5. Consult a Tax Professional: Seek guidance from a qualified tax expert.

The Growing Importance of Tax Compliance

The IRS is increasing its scrutiny of freelancers, gig workers, and online sellers.

Factors Driving IRS Scrutiny

1. Third-Party Reporting: Increased reporting from payment processors and e-commerce platforms.
2. Technological Advancements: Enhanced IRS capabilities to detect unreported income.
3. Focus on Gig Economy: Heightened attention to tax compliance in the gig economy.

By understanding and adhering to tax rules, freelancers and small business owners can avoid costly penalties and ensure compliance with federal tax laws.

As a professional – Revolutionize your tax workflow with our complete suite of tools: onboarding links, initial interviews, compliance planning, calendars, messaging, task management, and TaxMan for advanced tax research. Please sign up. Our resource directory also offers valuable links to assist in managing various financial and legal aspects of a business or individual.